IEEE Guide for Distribution Protection

by Kay Clinard, P.E. president of the UCA International Users Group

UCA International Users Group (UCAIug) was incorporated in 2001 as a not-for-profit users group.  Initially the focus was on supporting IEC61850 and substation automation. The UCAIug as well as its member groups (CIM, Open Smart Grid, and IEC61850) draws its membership from utility user, supplier, integrator, universities, consulting companies and individuals.    Our User Communities are led by the industry leaders and conveners of standards working groups and are responsible for revising and implementing standards roadmaps.  Members evaluate technical issues for the revision of each of the standards supported by the various Users Communities.

The mission of the UCA International Users Group is to enable utility integration through the deployment of open standards by providing a forum in which the various stakeholders in the utility industry can work cooperatively together as members of a common unbiased organization to:

  • Influence, select, and/or endorse open and public standards appropriate to the utility market based upon the needs of the membership.
  • Specify, develop and/or accredit product/system-testing programs that facilitate the field interoperability of products and systems based upon these standards.
  • Implement educational and promotional activities that increase awareness and deployment of these standards in the utility industry

While UCAIug does not write standards it works closely with those bodies that have primary responsibility for the completion of standards (notably IEC TC 57: Power Systems Management and Associated Information Exchange).  The UCAIug is a category "D" liaison organization with IEC TC57 WGs 10, 13, and 14.  UCAIug members have access to standards under development and provide grass roots input into the standards development process.

The Users Group is working on many areas of interest for different users where standards' bodies may not yet be active or where the interests of users go beyond the purview of the presently identified standards (such as the completion of users guides, industry education, transfer of technology, marketing support, identification of users needs and industry demonstrations to prove concepts).

UCAIug brings user communities for the IEC TC57 61850 and CIM standards, and Open Smart Grid standards, into one user community under the umbrella of the UCA International Users Group.  Each community includes a cross-section of industry stake holders in the implementation of smart grid technology.  Currently there are three user communities encompassing the modeling, communications, and automation of the electric utility from generation to meter.  These communities have developed into an active user community for the "Smart Grid" under the umbrella of the UCAIug.

It all began with one user community, twenty nine corporate members from seven countries, and six hundred forum users.  In the eight years since incorporation the organization has matured and grown  (Figure 1). Today UCAIug includes:

  • Three user communities
    • Open Distributed Resources
    • CIM and
    • IEC 61850
  • 135 utility, vendor, university, integrator corporate members from thirty-nine countries
  • Supporting six web sites, with over 2,400 SharePoint user accounts with a sustained growth of four new accounts each day. 
  • About half of the accounts are guest accounts as part of our 501c3 non-profit status and goal for wide spread support of standards
  • A Technical Oversight Committee for very active Sub Committees:
    • IEC 61850 Users Community.   The Standards Improvement Process outlined to the right has been implemented for IEC 61850.  The TISSUES and their resolution are maintained in a TISSUE Database.  This process has proven very useful managing the resolution of technical issues (Figure 2.)
    • CIM Users Community.  The CIMug has a CIM Model Manager (CMM), and actively supports users and development of models and interoperability testing for the IEC based CIM. 
    • OpenSmartGrid Users Community.  The UCAIug OpenSmartGridug actively supports the development, vetting, and validation of utility requirements, and use cases for OpenSmartGrid activities.
  • Harmonization Subcommittee for the standards represented by these User Communities          
  • Testing Subcommittee develops test scripts and certification procedures for the standards represented by these Users Communities.   UCAIug Testing Committee brings together industry stake holders to collect and resolve Technical Issues (TISSUES) for the IEC 61850 Quality Assurance Program.  Testing issues are reviewed and addressed by UCAIug Testing Committee members and QAP editors. Independent Accredited Test Laboratories provide feedback to the UCAIug QAP process.  As noted in the diagram to the right, a QAP can be difficult to coordinate and a process is needed to ensure feedback.  The UCAIug Testing Subcommittee has implemented an industry recognized  Quality Assurance Plan for IEC 61850 conformance testing with five accredited independent test labs, and the CIMug is active in interoperability testing
  • Focused Help Desks for each User Community
  • Collaboration Forums for each User Community
  • Hosting Project sites...UCTE, CIM, IEC61850...
  • In an effort to support the development of open standards, the UCAIug provides SharePoint hosting for standards working groups, and GoToMeeting/Webinar support for on-line meetings to encourage fast track development for:
    • All UCAIug User Communities
    • IEC TC57 WG's 10, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17 and 19.
    • CIGRE WG D2-24 (IEC TC57 Site)
  • UCAIug WGs are preparing for implementing a server with Subversion to be used as a repository for the management of industry models and use cases for CIM, OpenSmartGrid and IEC 61850 activities

Ad: My Dad Tests Multi-Ratio CTs ... and with the CT Analyser and the new CT SB2 it's all automated.
Ad: Basler Protective Relays Intertie Generator Feeder Now with IEC 61850
Ad: Protection made simple. HighPROTEC the 4th generation of power protection